Rebuttal

"Rebuttal" by Betsy Curtis is a mid-20th century science fiction novella that presents an opposing view to Arthur C. Clarke's "The Star," examining themes of faith, purpose, and immortality through a scientific perspective. The narrative tackles large philosophical questions about existence and divinity, all within the context of space exploration and human experience. The story centers on Father Niccolo Molina, a hospital pathologist, as he tries to understand the strange illness impacting Father Phillip Burt, who was part of a failed space expedition. As they talk, Father Phillip reveals that the crew's discovery of a universe without a visible plan or divine being has caused an existential crisis for him. Through their discussions, Father Niccolo makes the case that human consciousness strongly connects with individual cells, implying that life's core continues beyond death. Eventually, this philosophical journey results in a miracle recovery for Father Phillip, who rediscovers purpose and faith as he reconnects with his crew.