The Mystery of the Sycamore

"The Mystery of the Sycamore" by Carolyn Wells is a captivating mystery novel set in the early 20th century that revolves around Curtis Keefe, a secretary to ex-governor Samuel Appleby, and the enigmatic Wheeler family, led by Daniel Wheeler and his daughter Maida. The narrative explores themes of political schemes, family devotion, and personal beliefs through the dilemma of a conditional pardon and the conflicts between morals and expectations. The story begins with Keefe's daily life, interrupted by a significant letter summoning them to Sycamore Ridge, the Wheeler's residence. A long-standing rivalry between Daniel Wheeler and Appleby, originating from Wheeler's forgery conviction—a conviction Appleby conditionally pardoned—is uncovered. The intricacies of the Wheeler family relationships are examined, specifically Maida's commitment to her dad and her battle involving her feelings and the political aftermath of their situation. This sets the scene for a clash of values as the characters navigate personal relationships and greater political desires influencing their lives.